I like a good horror story, and I like a good thriller – just take a look at some of my past reviews. Give me a story that can keep me guessing, with characters I actually care about and enough suspense to make me want to keep turning the pages, and I’m a happy reader. Unfortunately, Allison Gunn’s Hive Mind didn’t quite deliver what I was looking for.
The story centers on Bee Torrance, a controversial horror performer whose disturbing antics are streamed online for her devoted followers, known as her Hive. Bee is married to Jacob Peyton, a powerful Hollywood manager who finds himself on trial for her brutal murder. The problem is that Jacob claims he can’t remember what happened. As journalists investigate Bee’s past and try to determine what really happened in that remote Appalachian cabin, the story moves between psychological horror, possible supernatural forces, and the question of just how much of the truth anyone really knows.
On paper, this sounds like the ingredients for a pretty entertaining thriller. There are secrets, a suspicious murder, strange happenings, and the possibility that something far more sinister than an ordinary crime is at work. I can certainly see the appeal.
My problem was getting there.
For roughly the first third of the book, I was thoroughly bored. The story takes far too long to get moving, and I found myself struggling to become invested in what was happening. Things do pick up during the final quarter, and there is some interesting material here. Unfortunately, by that point, I had largely stopped caring about the characters. It’s difficult to get excited about revelations and developments when you haven’t been given much reason to care about the people involved. Could part of the problem be that we don’t really have a main character? Bee Torrance might be the most interesting person in the book and she’s dead. And even with that, I simply wasn’t that interested in her.
I also have a hard time calling this a thriller. For me, too much of the book feels like reflection, looking back at events and examining what they might mean rather than building the kind of tension and forward momentum I expect from a thriller. We essentially know where things are headed from very early on, so much of the journey feels like waiting for the story to catch up with what we’ve already figured out.
This isn’t to say that a story needs to keep its ending a secret to be effective … sometimes the real pleasure comes from watching how everything unfolds. But if that’s the approach an author is taking, I need characters I can root for, worry about, or at least find fascinating. I just didn’t get enough of that here.
Allison Gunn clearly has some interesting ideas to work with, and the combination of online notoriety, disturbing horror, and Appalachian supernatural elements has potential (I understand that Appalachia has a big appeal to many readers, but I’ve never been invested in that culture). I just wish the storytelling had grabbed me sooner and given me a reason to care about the people caught up in it.
Looking for a good book? Hive Mind by Allison Gunn has just enough to keep the book from being a complete miss, particularly once the story finally gets interesting, but a thriller needs to do more than eventually get around to the good stuff. This simply takes too long to draw the reader in.
I received a digital copy of this book from the publisher, through Edelweiss, in exchange for an honest review.
3 stars
* * * * * *
Hive Mind
author: Allison Gunn
publisher: Atria Books
ISBN: 9781668218150
hardcover, 400 pages




Leave a Reply